The proof Ibn Shihab Al-Zuhuri was a fabricator!

One of the main things that make the rija'l(chains of transmission)weak in the Muwatta' is the narrations of the highly admirable by sunnis hadith scholar named;Ibn Shihab Al-Zuhuri!
Zuhuri was known to hide and turn back on the traditions of The Ahul Bayt!Muhammad Ibn Ishaq followed his steps in tradition.It was to the point that Imam Malik(Ra) & Ad-Dhahaabi(Ra)rejected Ibn Ishaq's traditions and thrown them out!

 [See Mizan al i'tidal fi naqd al-rijal](Sunni Source)

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The letter of Abu Hanifah to Uthman al-Batti(after being called Mur'jii')

The Epistle of Abū Hanifa to ‘Uthmān al-Battī[1] From Abū Ḥanīfa to ‘Uthmān al-Battī. Peace be unto you. I extol to you God, than whom there is no other god. As for what follows, I counsel the fear of God and obedience to Him; God suffices as reckoner and compensator. Your letter has reached me, and I have understood your advice in it. You say that you were moved to write it by what I had written to preserve you in the good and to advise you. You mention that it has reached you that I am of the Murji’a[2], and that I hold a True Believer may err, and that this distresses you, and that there is really no excuse among friends of God for a thing which keeps one apart from God ; that there is nothing by which one may be guided in what mere men create and innovate; t hat moral imperatives ( al-amr ) are only in what the Qur’ān brought and in what Muhammad , on whom be peace and God's blessing, preached and his Companions agreed upon until the people became divided; and that anythi...
Read more

Why do Shi'a call Ali(AS)name in the Adhan?

Image
Tahir Qawwal So...clearly Balil (ra) never was ordered to say this in Rasul (SAW)time or after.So why do we do it a Sunni brother asked! The answer: This is the maintenance of testifying Ali(AS)al-Murtaza's waliyyat !It is not part of adhan or considered " fardh "in our Madhab of the Shi'a !And these are our books and Maraja' that prove it is mu'akadah!...not fardh! Seyed Ali Sistani : Resalah,Masaleh No. :905 .(should be your first choice) Ayt Makarem Shirazi :  Masaleh No. : 843. Imam Khomeini :  Masaleh No. : 919. Ayt Alavi Gorgani :  Masaleh No. : 928. Ayt Sadeq Rouhani :  Masaleh No. : 925.  Ayt Mazaheri  Masaleh : No. : 729. Ayt Vahid Khorasani :  Masaleh No. : 928. Ayt Sobhani :  Masaleh No. : 885. Ayt Safi Golpayegani :  Masaleh No. : 928. Ayt Khamenei :  So'al No. : 456. Ayt Nouri Hamedani :  Masaleh No. : 920. Late Ayt Boroujerdi :  Masaleh No. : 928 . ...
Read more