The Myth Of Abdullah ibn Saba'
The Sunni ulema have for long time made up stories of a Yemenite Jew by the name of Abdullah ibn Saba';giving him credit to starting "a sect of Shi'a".Truth is;when asked to point out this issue in history,they never can site references!So we have decided to examine this analogically!
1)A "Yemenite Jew"living in Iraq in the time of Ali(AS)
Ali(AS)was known for expelling the Jews from medina after he found them in Medina upon His return!The only period in the time of sahabah(May Allah be pleased with the guided among them!)
we in two bodies!
The first;Those whom believed in Rasul(SAAW)and accepted Him.[Before the verse about them becoming enemies of Allah & eventually leading to The Battle Of The Trench!]
The Second;Those who were let back in Medina by Umar b. Khattab!
Now between these 2 periods Abdullah ibn Saba' would have had to convert to Islam firstly(and I ask you post the daleel of his conversion date and who gave him shahadah?)
And two; a Jew traveling from Yemen to be among Ali Al-Murtadha!(AS).
Now;let's do some history for all you timeline bandits!
This is a passage from wiki article(I claim no right to this passage!)
"Between June 1949 and September 1950, the overwhelming majority of Yemen's Jewish population was transported to Israel in Operation Magic Carpet. After several waves of persecution throughout Yemen, most Yemenite Jews now live in Israel, while smaller communities live in the United States and elsewhere. Only a handful remain in Yemen."
And you can find the link to this article here!
As you can see,history shows these Arab-Jews were persecuted by Arabs and migrated to Israel and other countries!Some one would have given Abdullah ibn Saba' a lift from Yemen to medina in order to give him shahadah!By believing this lie you are saying either or;Ali(AS)(istagfirAllah) or someone else brought him to Medina or Iraq for that matter!It is evident Jews couldn't just enter the lands of the Muslim-Arabs.The ones who remained behind paid the Jizya!
1)A "Yemenite Jew"living in Iraq in the time of Ali(AS)
Ali(AS)was known for expelling the Jews from medina after he found them in Medina upon His return!The only period in the time of sahabah(May Allah be pleased with the guided among them!)
we in two bodies!
The first;Those whom believed in Rasul(SAAW)and accepted Him.[Before the verse about them becoming enemies of Allah & eventually leading to The Battle Of The Trench!]
The Second;Those who were let back in Medina by Umar b. Khattab!
Now between these 2 periods Abdullah ibn Saba' would have had to convert to Islam firstly(and I ask you post the daleel of his conversion date and who gave him shahadah?)
And two; a Jew traveling from Yemen to be among Ali Al-Murtadha!(AS).
Now;let's do some history for all you timeline bandits!
This is a passage from wiki article(I claim no right to this passage!)
"Between June 1949 and September 1950, the overwhelming majority of Yemen's Jewish population was transported to Israel in Operation Magic Carpet. After several waves of persecution throughout Yemen, most Yemenite Jews now live in Israel, while smaller communities live in the United States and elsewhere. Only a handful remain in Yemen."
And you can find the link to this article here!
As you can see,history shows these Arab-Jews were persecuted by Arabs and migrated to Israel and other countries!Some one would have given Abdullah ibn Saba' a lift from Yemen to medina in order to give him shahadah!By believing this lie you are saying either or;Ali(AS)(istagfirAllah) or someone else brought him to Medina or Iraq for that matter!It is evident Jews couldn't just enter the lands of the Muslim-Arabs.The ones who remained behind paid the Jizya!
Comments
Post a Comment